Switching from Etsy to Shopify is an exciting move, but it often comes with one big challenge: starting fresh without your hard-earned customer feedback. Reviews are social proof that builds trust and gives new visitors confidence in your store. The good news is you don’t need to leave them behind; you can import Etsy reviews to Shopify quickly.
| What you’ll learn in this article ● Why Import Etsy Reviews to Shopify? ● How to Export Reviews from Etsy ● How to Import Etsy Reviews to Shopify ● Tips to Maximize Your Imported Reviews ● FAQs About Importing Etsy Reviews to Shopify |
Why Import Etsy Reviews to Shopify?
Moving from Etsy to Shopify means more than just switching platforms; it’s about carrying your hard-earned trust with you.
Preserve Social Proof Across Platforms
When you migrate from Etsy to Shopify, your reviews represent years of customer trust. Keeping them ensures your Shopify store doesn’t look like it’s starting from zero.
Those same reviews reassure visitors on Shopify product pages. Instead of questioning your credibility, shoppers see a proven track record from Etsy right away.
Boost Conversions With Reviews
Showing reviews on Shopify product pages can boost buyer confidence and reduce hesitation. In fact, displaying reviews or user ratings can increase conversion rates by up to 270% in controlled settings.
This means bringing Etsy reviews to Shopify isn’t just a nice-to-have; it’s a proven tactic to improve sales. The more authentic reviews you display, the smoother the path to checkout.
Save Time Building Reputation on Shopify
Building reviews from scratch takes months, and during that time, your Shopify store may feel empty to first-time buyers. This delay can cost you early momentum.
By importing Etsy reviews, you launch Shopify with a ready-made reputation. Customers instantly see that others already trust your brand and products.
Strengthen Your Shopify Brand Story
Reviews don’t only show ratings; they carry personal stories from your Etsy journey. Losing them would mean losing valuable narratives about your brand.
On Shopify, these stories help connect your past with your future. They make your store feel established and authentic, giving shoppers a stronger reason to trust your brand.
How to Export Reviews from Etsy?
Before you can import reviews into Shopify, you need to get them out of Etsy first. While Etsy doesn’t have a direct “Export Reviews” button, there are still ways to gather your customer feedback. This ensures you have the data ready when it’s time to move everything to your Shopify store.
The most common methods include:
- Download shop data in CSV: Go to Etsy Shop Manager > Settings > Download Data. From here, export shop information as a CSV file. Depending on your shop, customer feedback may be included.
- Copy reviews manually: If your reviews don’t appear in the CSV, open your Shop Manager dashboard and copy reviewer names, star ratings, and review text.
- Use a third-party tool: Some apps can extract Etsy reviews directly into spreadsheets, giving you a cleaner dataset to import into Shopify.
How to Import Etsy Reviews to Shopify
There are a few different ways to move reviews from Etsy to Shopify, depending on your needs and tech comfort.
Method 1: Manual Copy & Paste
If you only have a handful of reviews, manual entry might be enough.
Step 1: Open your reviews in your Etsy Shop Manager.
Step 2: Copy the reviewer name, star rating, and review text.
Step 3: In Shopify Admin, go to the relevant product, then the Reviews section (through your review app).
Step 4: Paste the review details and manually assign the star rating.
Step 5: Save and repeat the process for other reviews.
💡 Pro tip: Manual entry isn’t scalable, but it works if you’re just starting out with a few Etsy reviews.
Method 2: CSV File Import
This method works if you prefer handling data manually or if your review app doesn’t connect directly to Etsy.
Step 1: Export your Etsy reviews into a spreadsheet or copy them into a CSV file.
Step 2: Format the CSV file according to your Shopify review app’s requirements. Typical fields include:
- product_handle (Shopify product URL slug)
- reviewer_name
- rating (1–5)
- review_text
Step 3: In your chosen review app (like Judge.me or Fera), go to Settings > Import Reviews.
Step 4: Upload the CSV file, then map each column to the correct field.
Step 5: Confirm the import and check a few product pages on Shopify to make sure reviews are attached properly.
💡 Pro tip: This method is best for merchants who are comfortable with spreadsheets and want bulk control.
Method 3: Use an App (Recommended – No coding required)
The most efficient way to move your Etsy reviews to Shopify is with the Etsy Reviews Importer app. In just a few clicks, you can import both shop-level and product-specific reviews directly from Etsy, no coding or complex setup required. Once imported, reviews can be displayed anywhere in your Shopify store, from product pages and collection pages to your homepage and even the cart page.
This makes your social proof visible at every key point of the buying journey, turning visitors into paying customers. The app gives you full flexibility to embed authentic Etsy reviews, instantly build credibility with real ratings, and strengthen brand trust. Plus, it comes with 24/7 support if you ever need help tailoring the setup.
Overview: Import all your Etsy reviews to Shopify in just a few clicks.
Key Features:
- Automatically fetch reviews from your Etsy shop.
- Transfer customer names, ratings, and review text.
- Integrates seamlessly with your Shopify product pages.
Pricing: Free plan available with optional upgrades.
Best for: Sellers migrating fully from Etsy to Shopify who want speed and ease.
Tips to Maximize Your Imported Reviews
Style Them to Match Your Brand
Imported reviews only shine if they blend seamlessly with your Shopify store design. Adjust fonts, colors, and layouts so the reviews feel like a natural part of your brand identity.
Moreover, consistency across your store builds trust. When reviews visually match your Shopify theme, customers see a professional and unified shopping experience.
Add Visuals for Extra Trust
Reviews with plain text are valuable, but adding photos makes them even more convincing. Pair your imported Etsy reviews with product images or customer-submitted photos inside your Shopify product pages.
In addition, visuals help shoppers imagine the product in real life. This small step turns reviews from simple words into powerful social proof across your Shopify store.
Feature Best Reviews on Key Pages
Not all reviews need equal visibility; highlight your strongest ones where they matter most. On Shopify, that means showcasing top-rated reviews on your homepage, product detail pages, and even collection pages.
As a result, visitors encounter social proof at every stage of their shopping journey. The right reviews in the right places make it easier for customers to trust and complete their purchase.
FAQs about Importing Etsy Reviews to Shopify
1. Will my Etsy star ratings transfer correctly to Shopify?
Yes, if you use a dedicated import app, both review text and star ratings transfer seamlessly. Manual copy-paste may not preserve stars, so an app is the safer choice.
2. Can I import Etsy reviews into Shopify without linking my Etsy account?
Some apps allow CSV uploads if you don’t want to connect directly. However, direct integration is faster and reduces formatting errors.
3. Can I choose which reviews to display on Shopify?
Absolutely. Most review apps let you filter by rating, product, or date before publishing. That way, you control what shows up on your storefront.
4. What happens to new reviews I get on Etsy after migration?
Reviews don’t sync automatically unless the app supports ongoing syncing. For most sellers, Shopify becomes the main platform, so focus on collecting fresh reviews there.
5. Is there a risk of duplicate reviews appearing?
If you import the same data twice, duplicates may occur. Good apps usually detect and prevent duplicates, but it’s best to double-check your product pages.